Repeal and Replace Obamacare|
April 14, 2014
The announced departure of HHS Secretary Kathleen Sibelius marks the end of a
chapter of American history. Sibelius, aside from President Obama, has been the
most prominent public face on the signature initiative of the Obama
administration – the Affordable Health Care Act.
The question before Americans today is whether we are concluding the first
chapter of a dream come true or whether this may be the beginning of the end of
I’m hoping Americans will wake up and see Obamacare for the nightmare it is.
Victory dances are taking place in the “dream come true” camp that over seven
million have now signed up for Obamacare plans through federal and state
A lot of analysis is pouring forth about what this seven million actually means
and to what extent this has anything to do with the claims of what Obamacare was
supposed to do – deliver more affordable quality health care to more Americans.
But sometimes too much data and analysis gets you lost in in the forest.
The headline that should be flashing in front of us is that today, well into the
sixth year of the Obama presidency, the American economy, once a dynamic engine
of growth, is still is a wheezing, struggling, underperforming clunker of an
We should be making a direct connection between this and the imposition of the
Affordable Care Act on the American public.
Amid the celebration of the seven million plus have who have signed up, let’s
not forget the Congressional Budget Office report in February projecting that
Obamacare will shrink the American economy by 2.5 million jobs.
The specific factors CBO points to that will cause this shrinkage of jobs are
the exchange subsidies, expansion of Medicaid, penalties on employers, and new
taxes on labor.
We don’t have to sit and wonder about the reasonableness of CBO’s estimates.
We’re already seeing these factors at work today.
Again, well into the sixth year of the Obama administration, unemployment is
still at 6.7 percent, well above what has been historically considered the
unemployment rate of a “full employment” economy – 5 percent.
The Wall Street Journal reports that the percentage of working age Americans who
are working or actively seeking employment stands at 63.2 percent - “the lowest
in three and half decades.”
According to Federal Reserve chairman Janet Yellin, “While there has been steady
progress, there is no doubt that the economy and the job market are not back to
Now, certainly, the American economy is not all bad news.
But just look at where the incredible things are happening. They are happening
in areas where individuals are left free to innovate. Where government is not
controlling what businesses and individuals do.
The world is changing in front of us due to technological innovations that no
one – certainly no government bureaucrat - could have dreamed of.
Technology is leading America to energy independence, something no one would
have dreamed even 10 years ago.
When individuals are free to innovate and create, and when there are rewards to
be gained commensurate with risks taken, miracles happen.
The same thing could be happening in health care.
But it’s not and won’t because government has taken it by the neck and is making
this critical sector of our economy more like the US Postal Service than like
Apple or Google or Amazon.com.
Making innovation and creativity impossible, penalizing business, taxing work in
one fifth of the American economy is no formula for a great American future.
Bureaucratization of health care is dragging down our whole economy.
Better, cheaper, more innovative health care won’t be delivered by government
and politicians. It will be delivered by the American people if politicians will
get out of the way and let them do it.
Let’s face it. Obamacare was a huge mistake. We should repeal and replace it.
Star Parker is founder and president of CURE, the Center for Urban Renewal
and Education, a 501c3 think tank which explores and promotes market based
public policy to fight poverty, as well as author of the newly revised Uncle
Sam's Plantation: How Big Government Enslaves America's Poor and What We Can do